How to Get Action with Your Staff Reviews

Performance Management and Appraisal

"My 1 to 1 sessions seem to just fizzle out at the end of each one.

Usually, because we run out of time and need to get back to the workplace.

How can I overcome this?"

Management Development

This was a great question that was asked by a delegate during a Management Development Programme we were running for them.

Let's take a look at some solutions....

Does the following sound familiar to you?

Coaching |Session

You are coming to the end of your 1-to-1 meeting or coaching session with one of your direct reports.

You have both talked a great game and discussed some really worthwhile topics but time is now against you both and you need to come to a rapid close!

Now which of the following happens to you?

Three Possible Outcomes

"Ok DIRECT REPORT that was a great session I will write an email of the action points and send them to you"


"Ok DIRECT REPORT, that was a great session, we'd better get back" [note, no close or follow up]


"OK, DIRECT REPORT, let me summarise what we have discussed, we have covered XYZ and ABC, you will do GHJ and I will do KLP"

Three Scenarios

Normally when a development session comes to a close, you end up with one of the three scenarios above.

They either:

1. Just come to an end with no summary of action points or who is doing what.


2. You as the manager decide to get all of the action points down in an email to send them to your direct report.


3. You summarise the meeting of what was discussed and take responsibility for communicating the action points.

None Of The Above

I recommend that you do not use any of the above!!!!

If I had to choose it would be # 3 but instead here is what I recommend that you do....

Firstly you should concentrate more on the closure of a session than you have been doing. What is the point of a meeting if you do not concentrate on WHAT NEEDS to be done and WHEN rather than the WHY?

Leave yourself more time than the normal 5 minutes you do at the moment to close the session.

Time To Close

As a general rule of thumb, if you are running a 60-minute session you should start to wrap up at the 40-minute mark leaving a good 20 minutes for the close.

So that's my first recommendation.

My second recommendation is that to close you ask your direct report to summarise the meeting there and then and also ask them to document all of the action points and get them to send them TO YOU!

Here's why:

1. You are making the direct report responsible for the meeting and the action points

2. You are ensuring that they have understood and listened to what you were both saying

3. If you start to do this during every session you will condition the direct report to pay closer attention to what is being said during the meeting because they know they will have to summarise and send you the action points at the end of it!

4. It lightens your workload [yippy I hear you shout!]

5. It promotes empowerment and shared responsibility for the development of the direct report.

6. You are acting as a leader rather than a note taker and backside wiper! (sorry about that last statement but I am sure you know where I am coming from with it!)

Taking Responsibility

So, start to get your staff members to take more responsibility during your 1 to 1 coaching sessions.

The result will be awesome I can assure you!

This article was contributed by Sean McPheat

Performance Management and Appraisal Training

Impact Factory runs

Open Performance Management Courses

Tailored Performance Management Training

Tailored Management Training

and personalised

One-to-One Executive Coaching

for anyone interested in

Performance Management

Performance Management Training in London

Training Course Accreditation

To ensure that the courses you attend are of the highest quality, offering the best professional tuition possible, all our Open Courses are evaluated and accredited.

This accredited course is suitable for corporate and public sector Continuing Professional Development Plans and Portfolios.

Read about Trainer Accreditation